Sunday, February 21, 2016

Don't use the greater than sign in programming


One simple thing that comes up time and time again is the use of the greater than sign as part of a conditional while programming. Removing it cleans up code, here's why:

Conditionals can be confusing

Let's say that I want to check that something is between 5 and 10. 
There are many ways I can do this

All of these mean the same thing... Wait, did I actually do all that right? Sorry, one of those is incorrect. Go ahead and find out which one, I'll wait...

If you remove the use of the greater than sign then only 2 options remain:
(x < 10 && 5 < x)
which is a stupid option because it implies 10 < 5 and
(5 <&& x < 10)

This is a nice way of expressing "x is between 5 and 10" because it is literally between 5 and 10.

It's also a nice way of expressing that "x is outside the limits of 5 and 10"
(x < 5 || 10 < x)

Again, this expresses it nicely because x is literally outside of 5 to 10.

Simple. Clear. Consistent.

This is such a nice way to express numbers I wonder why programming languages allow for the greater than sign ( > ) at all.

But why is this so expressive?

The Number line

Here's how you represent between 5 and 10 on a number line vs code:
number line of between 5 to 10
(5 <&& x < 10)


Here's how you represent outside of  5 and 10 on a number line vs code:
number line of outside 5 to 10
(x < 5 || 10 < x)


On a number line everything to the left is less than the numbers to the right, so these two ways of representing the relationship between things matches up.

Combinatorics

This problem gets much worse as the conditional grows. For example
 number line of between -5 and -1 or between 2 and 4
((-5 <&& x < -1) || (2 <&& x < 4))

Has 15 other possible ways to be expressed if you  include the greater than sign and don't make your expressions conform to the number line.





82 comments:

Myk said...

That's a smart trick. I know from my personal coding that any time I start writing the bracket tokens, I'd better look extra closely and probably test what I'm doing because I tend to write a lot of bugs in that kind of code.

Tartley said...

Agreed all over.

FWIW, in Python, you can condense a little bit more by chaining inequalities: "5 < x < 10" means the logical 'and' of "5 < x" and "x < 10". And in common with your article, this also becomes impenetrable with > signs.

rob said...

You might want to fix the "outside" case to use "<=", or change the number line pictures, which seem to imply 5 and 10 are "outside".

Marino van der Heijden said...

How simple it may seem it is indeed an issue to do it right. Working with integers is still the most easy one although you don't explicitly memtion if you want to include or exclude the boundary values. It becomes even more difficult if you're working with doubles or datetime objects. Then suddenly broken numbers or the time of the day also play part of the equation.
I've seen this go 'horrably' wrong several time, esoecially with datetime objects. Where analists write "from x until y" it is not clear wheather to include x and y or only include x and exclude y. To be clear there are enough ways to solve this but clear communication is the best one...

Unknown said...

How about writing a simple function like between(x1, x2) and replace all of that notation

Joe McCay said...

Why write a function for such a trivial expression? You will add to the cost of the overall method in which the method between appears. Remember, this will be called for each iteration.

Tim Ojo said...

I think its perfectly fine to write small, "trivial" functions if they improve the expressiveness and readability of your code. Making micro-optimizations such as inlining expressions should probably be left to the compiler, which does a pretty good job at those kinds of optimizations. This allows the programmer to focus on optimizing the parts of the code that really need it, after they've profiled and identified a hot spot.

Unknown said...

> all of that notation

ahahahahaha!!!

Llewellyn Falco said...

> How about writing a simple function like between(x1, x2) and replace all of that notation

You will need 3 parameters in many languages, so between (x1,x2,x3) . so then the question becomes is the middle number the between value? or the first/last?

I do not care about the method overhead. Many languages will have it inlined anyways by runtime and it's a trival amount of time. Much prefer to optimize for readability and change rather than processor time.

> You might want to fix the "outside" case to use "<="
Yes, you are right.

Ollie Ford said...

Using the middle for the `x` has a nice 'symmetry' with the meaning. If I were to do this, I'd call it something other than 'between' to make this more clear; perhaps `is_ordered(l, x, u)`.

Tartley said...

I'm the biggest fan in the world of creating functions to improve the expressiveness and readability of code, but I don't think that in this case it does so. The original expression is so clear and explicit that replacing it with a function call actually obscures important details of the operation such as the boundary conditions (i.e. is it '<' or '<=' for the start and end boundary?) Nothing that can't be figured out, with a quick 'go to definition', but in requiring the reader to do that, you've actually made the code harder to read, not easier.

Robert Blair said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Greg Jorgensen said...

What is cleaner or easier to read comes down to personal taste. But how to express "all numbers greater than 1" without '>'?

Tartley said...

Personal taste is certainly a factor in some things, but not in everything. It's worth having the discussion. And within a single team, it sometimes helps to have a chat like this so that everyone can converge on a single style. If the decision is controversial, then perhaps it isn't appropriate. But a discussion like this one is often all that's needed for everyone on the team to realise they all feel the same way about it.

Llewellyn Falco said...

But how to express "all numbers greater than 1" without '>'?

1 < allNumbers

boon kiat han said...

1 < X

Michael Norrish said...

Your "only two options remain" are the same except that you have swapped what is on either side of the &&. Maybe you meant

10 < x && x < 5

for one of them.

Андреев Кирилл said...

You also can have function/method x.inBetween(low, hi) of between(lo, x, hi) and wrap it in not(). Its far more readable than x < 5 || 10 < x, which is poor-written !(5 <= x && x <= 10).

internot said...

TLDR: use <= operator.

The operator < is *exclusive*, which generally is not what is meant when you say "pick a number between 5 and 10". The number lines also show it as inclusive. In a discrete setting, the expression (2 < x && x < 4) is only true for x=3. More correct would be to use the <= operator. One can use less intuitive inclusive boundaries 1 x || x > 10).

akmal niazi khan said...

Programming is very interesting and creative thing if you do it with love. Your blog code helps a lot to beginners to learn programming from basic to advance level. I really love this blog because I learn a lot from here and this process is still continuing.
Love from Pro Programmer

Manoj Kumar said...

nic post...
http://mkniit.blogspot.in

Daniel Hoffmann said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
niaziakmal khan said...

This blog awesome and i learn a lot about programming from here.The best thing about this blog is that you doing from beginning to experts level.

Love from Pprogramming

Anna Li said...

wholesale nfl jerseys

wholesale jerseys

wholesale Jerseys free shipping

cheap jerseys free shipping

wholesale jerseys

cheap jerseys

Wholesale Jerseys

wholesale jerseys from china

wholesale authentic jerseys

cheap authentic jerseys

cheap jerseys

sitemap

sunglasses

Anna Li said...

FakeSunglassesWholesale Sitemap

cheap oakley holbrook sunglasses

cheap oakley sunglasses

Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Online

Oakley Holbrook Sunglasses UK

Oakley Frogskins Sunglasses

Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses

Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses

fake ray bans sunglasses

Discount Ray Ban Sunglasses

replica ray ban sunglasses

cheap ray ban sunglasses

knockoff ray ban sunglasses

cheap ray bans sunglasses

fake ray ban sunglasses

wholesale ray ban sunglasses

shoes

ShoesBootsCheap Sitemap

Cheap Christian Louboutin Shoes

Replica Air Jordan Shoes

Discount Nike Shoes

Cheap Air Jordan Shoes

Cheap Nike Shoes

Cheap Air Jordan Shoes Free Shipping

Authentic Air Jordan Shoes

Anna Li said...

cheap air jordans

Fake Nike Air Shoes

cheap nike shoes

cheap jordans shoes

Cheap Jordan Basketball Shoes

Wholesale Cheap Jerseys

Authentic NBA Jerseys

Authentic NBA Jerseys Wholesale

cheap mlb jerseys

Cheap NFL Jerseys

Cheap Authentic NBA Jerseys

Cheap Authentic Soccer Jerseys

Cheap Basketball Jerseys

cheap nba jerseys

Cheap Nba Jerseys Free Shipping

Cheap NBA Jerseys From China

Cheap NBA Jerseys uk

Cheap NFL Jerseys outlet

Cheap NFL Jerseys supply

cheap NHL jerseys free shipping

Cheap Soccer Jerseys Free Shipping

Fake NBA Jerseys

Replica NBA Jerseys

Wholesale Basketball Jerseys

Wholesale NBA Jerseys

Wholesale nfl jerseys

Anna Li said...

wholesale nhl jerseys paypal

cheap nhl jerseys

youth nhl jerseys

wholesale mlb jerseys

cheap mlb jerseys

cheap nhl jerseys

wholesale nhl jerseys

cheap replica jerseys

wholesale jerseys online

cheap authentic jerseys

cheap jerseys

wholesale authentic jerseys

Cheap nfl super bowl jerseys

cheap nhl jerseys

wholesale basketball jerseys

cheap basketball jerseys

cheap mlb jerseys free shipping

cheap mlb authentic jerseys

mlb jerseys cheap

cheap nfl jerseys

cheap authentic jerseys

cheap authentic nfl jerseys

replica nhl jerseys

cheap replica jerseys

cheap jerseys online

Anna Li said...

cheap jerseys free shipping<

cheap mlb jerseys

Cheap nba jerseys

cheap nfl jerseys uk

cheap super bowl jerseys

cheap nfl Jerseys online

cheap nfl jerseys paypal

cheap football jerseys

cheap nfl jerseys

cheap custom nfl jerseys

discount nfl jerseys

cheap nfl football jerseys

wholesale nfl jerseys

nfl ferseys cheap

wholesale nfl jerseys

cheap replica nfl jerseys

wholesale cheap nfl jerseys

Cheap nfl jerseys free shipping

Cheap nhl jerseys

Wholesale nike nfl jerseys

cheap nike jerseys

cheap soccer jerseys online

Anna Li said...

cheap soccer jerseys

Cheap jerseys from china

wholesale jerseys from china

cheap jerseys china

wholesale cheap jerseys

wholesale jerseys free shipping

wholesale nfl jerseys free shipping

cheap authentic jerseys

Cheap Replica MLB Jerseys

discount nba jerseys

cheap nba jerseys

cheap nfl jerseys

wholesale nfl jerseys

discount nfl jerseys

wholesale nfl jerseys

nfl jerseys cheap

Cheap nhl jerseys

cheap nhl jerseys free shipping

cheap nhl hockey jerseys

NHL Hockey Jerseys Cheap

custom ice hockey jerseys

cheap replica nhl jerseys

wholesale nhl hoceky jerseys

cheap nhl jerseys canada

Anna Li said...

cheap nhl jerseys online

cheap custom nhl jerseys

wholesale nhl jerseys

cheap nhl jerseys

wholesale nhl jerseys

wholesale nhl jerseys canada

cheap nhl authentic jerseys

cheap nike nfl jerseys

wholesale nike nfl jerseys

cheap nike jerseys

cheap jerseys from china

wholesale authentic jerseys

cheap football jerseys

wholesale sports jerseys

wholesale super bowl jerseys

cheap bowl Jerseys

discount jerseys online

cheap jerseys wholesale

discount super bowl jersey

cheap authentic nba jerseys

cheap authentic jerseys

cheap authentic jerseys

cheap nfl authentic jerseys

Anna Li said...

discount authentic jerseys

replica sports jerseys

replica football jerseys

replica nfl football jerseys

tampa bay lightning jerseys

cheap replica football jerseys

new arizona coyotes jerseys

fc barcelona jerseys

cheap jerseys online

discount jerseys free shipping

cheap womens jerseys

cheap jerseys free shipping

cheap mlb jerseys

replica mlb jerseys

discount mlb jerseys

wholesale mlb jerseys

cheap nba houston rockets jerseys

wholesale nba jerseys

cheap nba jerseys wholesale

cheap nba jerseys

Anna Li said...

cheap nba jerseys free shipping

wholesale nba jerseys

discount nba jerseys

wholesale nba jerseys

nba jerseys wholesale

cheap nba jerseys

cheap nba jerseys from china

cheap nba jerseys online

cheap nba free shipping

wholesale nba jerseys

cheap nba jerseys

cheap nfl jerseys for sale

cheap nfl jerseys free shipping

wholesale nfl jerseys

cheap nfl authentic jerseys

cheap nfl jerseys

nhl jerseys cheap

cheap nhl jerseys

cheap nhl jerseys online

custom nhl Jerseys

cheap nhl jerseys canada

cheap custom nhl jerseys

wholesale nhl jerseys

cheap nhl jerseys from china

Anna Li said...

cheap nike jerseys from china

wholesale nike jerseys from china

wholesale nike jerseys

cheap nike nfl jerseys

cheap nike sports jerseys

cheap nike jerseys

cheap nike nfl jerseys

cheap soccer jerseys

wholesale soccer jerseys

wholesale soccer jerseys

cheap soccer jerseys

colts super bowl jerseys

patriots super bowl jerseys

super bowl jerseys

cheap super bowl jerseys

patriots super bowl jersey

super bowl jerseys

super bowl jerseys

new england patriots super bowl jerseys

wholesale super bowl jerseys

cheap authentic super bowl jerseys

cheap jerseys from china

discount jerseys online

wholesale authentic elite jerseys

wholesale authentic jerseys

wholesale authentic nfl jerseys

Anna Li said...

cheap vancouver canucks jerseys

cheap youth jerseys

cheap real madrid jerseys

wholesale youth jerseys

cheap jerseys

cheap stitched jerseys

cheap kids jerseys

cheap jerseys wholesale

cheap jerseys

wholesale jerseys

wholesale nba jerseys free shipping

wholesale nba jerseys

wholesale jerseys free shipping

cheap nfl jerseys

replica nhl jerseys

cheap NHL Jerseys online

NHL Womens Jerseys

Discount NHL Jerseys

Custom Hockey Jerseys

cheap hockey jerseys

Replica NFL Jerseys

Anaheim Ducks jerseys

Cheap NBA jerseys

Anna Li said...

Wholesale Hockey jerseys

Wholesale NFL Jerseys

Cheap Montreal Canadiens Jerseys

cheap custom nhl jerseys

WHOLESALE NFL JERSEYS

CHEAP NFL JERSEYS

wholesale Soccer jerseys

Wholesale Cheap Sports Jerseys

discount jerseys

Authentic NFL Jerseys

Cheap NHL Jerseys

About Jerseys News

cheap jerseys wholesale

Best Shoes news Website

Sitemap-Shoes City SiteMap

Fashion Sunglasses News Website

Sitemap CheapSunglassesFreeShipping

Best Popular Sports news & Lifestyle news Website

Sitemap

Cold News SiteMap

Fashion News SiteMap

Sports News SiteMap

Replica Air Jordan

Fake oakley sunglasses

Anna Li said...

cheap ray ban sunglasses

Wholesale cheap Jerseys

cheap jerseys

cheap super bowl jerseys

cheap moncler jackets

wholesale cheap jerseys online

wholesale super bowl jerseys 2016

Buy Wholesale Cheap Free Shipping China

ShopCartBoss Home SiteMap

Cheap Pandora Store

Sitemap

Cheap Pandora

Wholesale Pandora charms

cheap Pandora Charms

Pandora Charms cheap

Pandora Jewelry

Wholesale Pandora

mlb jerseys

nba jerseys

ncaa jerseys

nfl jerseys

nhl jerseys

nike nfl jerseys

soccer jerseys

Anna Li said...

cheap caps
Wholesale MLB Jerseys
Wholesale NBA Jerseys
Wholesale NCAA Jerseys
Wholesale NFL Jerseys

Anna Li said...

[url=http://www.cheapjerseysfree.us/]wholesale nfl jerseys[/url]
[url=http://www.wholesalerjersey.com/]wholesale jerseys[/url]
[url=http://www.cheapjerseysoff.com/]cheap nfl jerseys[/url]
[url=http://www.cheapwholesalejerseysshipping.com/]cheap jerseys free shipping[/url]
[url=http://www.wholesalejerseyscheapforsale.com/]wholesale jerseys[/url]
[url=http://www.WholesaleJerseysCheaponline.com/]Wholesale Jerseys[/url]
[url=http://www.wholesalejerseyscheapfromchina.com/]wholesale jerseys from china[/url]
[url=http://www.wholesalecheapauthenticjerseys.com/]wholesale authentic jerseys[/url]

Anna Li said...

Cheap football jerseys
Cheap jerseys wholesale
Replica Super Bowl Jerseys
Cheap jerseys wholesale free shipping
Wholesale nhl jerseys
cheap nhl jerseys wholesale
cheap nhl jerseys canada
replica nhl jerseys
cheap nfl jerseys online
cheap jerseys From china

Anna Li said...

cheap nfl jerseys china
cheap mlb jerseys
wholesale authentic jerseys
cheap jerseys china
NFL Jerseys Wholesale
Colts super bowl jerseys

Anna Li said...

China nfl jerseys
cheap sports jerseys
cheap football jerseys
discount nfl jerseys
cheap mlb jerseys
cheap nba jerseys china
nhl jerseys cheap
Cheap Real Madrid Jersey
Cheap vancouver canucks jersey

Anna Li said...

Wholesale MLB jerseys
Wholesale Sports Jerseys
Customized nfl team jerseys
cheap football jerseys
Wholesale basketball jerseys
sunglasses
FakeSunglassesWholesale Sitemap

Anna Li said...

cheap oakley holbrook sunglasses
cheap oakley sunglasses
Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Online
Oakley Holbrook Sunglasses UK
Oakley Frogskins Sunglasses
Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses
Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses
fake ray bans sunglasses

Anna Li said...

Discount Ray Ban Sunglasses
replica ray ban sunglasses
cheap ray ban sunglasses
knockoff ray ban sunglasses
cheap ray bans sunglasses
fake ray ban sunglasses
wholesale ray ban sunglasses
shoes
ShoesBootsCheap Sitemap

Anna Li said...

Cheap Christian Louboutin Shoes
Replica Air Jordan Shoes
Discount Nike Shoes
Cheap Air Jordan Shoes
Cheap Nike Shoes
Cheap Air Jordan Shoes Free Shipping
Authentic Air Jordan Shoes
cheap air jordans
Fake Nike Air Shoes

Anna Li said...

Cheap NFL Jerseys Wholesale
Cheap Replica NFL Jerseys
Wholesale NFL Jerseys Free Shipping
Wholesale NFL Jerseys
Cheap NHL Jerseys
Cheap NHL Authentic Jerseys
Cheap NHL Jerseys Free Shipping
Cheap Replica NHL Jerseys

Anna Li said...

Replica NHL Jerseys
Wholesale Authentic NHL Jerseys
Cheap NHL Jerseys
Wholesale Hockey Jerseys
Wholesale NHL Jerseys Free Shipping
Wholesale NHL Jerseys
Cheap nfl nike jerseys free shipping
Cheap nike nfl jerseys

Anna Li said...

Replica nike nfl jerseys
Wholesale nike nfl jerseys
Nike Jerseys
replica soccer jerseys
cheap soccer jerseys
cheap soccer jerseys free Shipping
Custom soccer jerseys
Wholesale soccer jerseys

Anna Li said...

Cheap super bowl jerseys
Cheap super bowl jerseys free shipping
super bowl jerseys
super bowl champion jerseys
Wholesale super bowl jerseys
wholesale Jerseys free shipping
Authentic NBA Jerseys

Anna Li said...

Authentic NBA Jerseys Wholesale
cheap mlb jerseys
Cheap NFL Jerseys
Cheap Authentic NBA Jerseys
Cheap Authentic Soccer Jerseys
Cheap Basketball Jerseys
cheap nba jerseys
Cheap Nba Jerseys Free Shipping
Cheap NBA Jerseys From China
Cheap NBA Jerseys uk

Anna Li said...

Cheap NFL Jerseys outlet
Cheap NFL Jerseys supply
cheap NHL jerseys free shipping
Cheap Soccer Jerseys Free Shipping
Fake NBA Jerseys
Replica NBA Jerseys
Wholesale Basketball Jerseys
Wholesale NBA Jerseys
Wholesale nfl jerseys

Anna Li said...

wholesale nhl jerseys paypal
cheap nhl jerseys
youth nhl jerseys
wholesale mlb jerseys
cheap mlb jerseys
cheap nhl jerseys
wholesale nhl jerseys
cheap replica jerseys
wholesale jerseys online
cheap authentic jerseys

Anna Li said...

replica nhl jerseys
cheap replica jerseys
cheap jerseys online
cheap jerseys free shipping
cheap mlb jerseys
Cheap nba jerseys
cheap nfl jerseys uk
cheap super bowl jerseys

Anna Li said...

cheap nfl Jerseys online
cheap nfl jerseys paypal
cheap football jerseys
cheap nfl jerseys
cheap custom nfl jerseys
discount nfl jerseys
cheap nfl football jerseys
wholesale nfl jerseys
nfl ferseys cheap

Anna Li said...

wholesale nfl jerseys
cheap replica nfl jerseys
wholesale cheap nfl jerseys
Cheap nfl jerseys free shipping
Cheap nhl jerseys
Wholesale nike nfl jerseys
cheap nike jerseys
cheap soccer jerseys online
cheap soccer jerseys
Cheap jerseys from china

Anna Li said...

wholesale jerseys from china
cheap jerseys china
wholesale cheap jerseys
wholesale jerseys free shipping
wholesale nfl jerseys free shipping
cheap authentic jerseys
Cheap Replica MLB Jerseys

Anna Li said...

discount nba jerseys
cheap nba jerseys
cheap nfl jerseys
wholesale nfl jerseys
discount nfl jerseys
wholesale nfl jerseys
nfl jerseys cheap

Anna Li said...

Cheap nhl jerseys
cheap nhl jerseys free shipping
cheap nhl hockey jerseys
NHL Hockey Jerseys Cheap
custom ice hockey jerseys
cheap replica nhl jerseys
wholesale nhl hoceky jerseys
cheap nhl jerseys canada

Anna Li said...

cheap nhl jerseys online
cheap custom nhl jerseys
wholesale nhl jerseys
cheap nhl jerseys
wholesale nhl jerseys
wholesale nhl jerseys canada
cheap nhl authentic jerseys
cheap nike nfl jerseys
wholesale nike nfl jerseys

Anna Li said...

cheap nike jerseys
cheap jerseys from china
wholesale authentic jerseys
cheap football jerseys
wholesale sports jerseys
wholesale super bowl jerseys
cheap bowl Jerseys
discount jerseys online

Anna Li said...

cheap jerseys wholesale
discount super bowl jersey
cheap authentic nba jerseys
cheap authentic jerseys
cheap authentic jerseys
cheap nfl authentic jerseys
discount authentic jerseys
replica sports jerseys
replica football jerseys
replica nfl football jerseys

Anna Li said...

tampa bay lightning jerseys
cheap replica football jerseys
new arizona coyotes jerseys
fc barcelona jerseys
cheap jerseys online
discount jerseys free shipping
cheap womens jerseys
cheap jerseys free shipping
cheap mlb jerseys

Anna Li said...

replica mlb jerseys
discount mlb jerseys
wholesale mlb jerseys
cheap nba houston rockets jerseys
wholesale nba jerseys
cheap nba jerseys wholesale
cheap nba jerseys
cheap nba jerseys free shipping
wholesale nba jerseys
discount nba jerseys

Anna Li said...

nhl jerseys cheap
cheap nhl jerseys
cheap nhl jerseys online
custom nhl Jerseys
cheap nhl jerseys canada
cheap custom nhl jerseys
wholesale nhl jerseys
cheap nhl jerseys from china
cheap nike jerseys from china

Anna Li said...

wholesale nike jerseys from china
wholesale nike jerseys
cheap nike nfl jerseys
cheap nike sports jerseys
cheap nike jerseys
cheap nike nfl jerseys
cheap soccer jerseys
wholesale soccer jerseys
wholesale soccer jerseys

Anna Li said...

cheap soccer jerseys
colts super bowl jerseys
patriots super bowl jerseys
super bowl jerseys
cheap super bowl jerseys
patriots super bowl jersey
super bowl jerseys
super bowl jerseys
new england patriots super bowl jerseys
wholesale super bowl jerseys

Anna Li said...

cheap authentic super bowl jerseys
cheap jerseys from china
discount jerseys online
wholesale authentic elite jerseys
wholesale authentic jerseys
wholesale authentic nfl jerseys
cheap vancouver canucks jerseys
cheap youth jerseys
cheap real madrid jerseys
wholesale youth jerseys

Anna Li said...

cheap jerseys
cheap stitched jerseys
cheap kids jerseys
cheap jerseys wholesale
cheap jerseys
wholesale jerseys
wholesale nba jerseys free shipping
wholesale nba jerseys

Anna Li said...

wholesale jerseys free shipping
cheap nfl jerseys
wholesale Soccer jerseys
discount jerseys
Authentic NFL Jerseys
Cheap NHL Jerseys
About Jerseys News
Best Shoes news Website
Fashion Sunglasses News Website
Buy Wholesale Cheap Free Shipping China

Anna Li said...

cheap nfl jerseys
Wholesale Jerseys
Cheap NHL Jerseys
Cheap NBA Jerseys
wholesale nfl jerseys
Cheap Football Jerseys
wholesale Jerseys free shipping
Authentic NBA Jerseys
Authentic NBA Jerseys Wholesale
cheap mlb jerseys
Cheap NFL Jerseys
Cheap Authentic NBA Jerseys
Cheap Authentic Soccer Jerseys
Cheap Basketball Jerseys
cheap nba jerseys
Cheap Nba Jerseys Free Shipping
Cheap NBA Jerseys From China
Cheap NBA Jerseys uk
Cheap NFL Jerseys outlet
Cheap NFL Jerseys supply

Anna Li said...

cheap NHL jerseys free shipping
Cheap Soccer Jerseys Free Shipping
Fake NBA Jerseys
Replica NBA Jerseys
Wholesale Basketball Jerseys
Wholesale NBA Jerseys
Wholesale nfl jerseys
wholesale nhl jerseys paypal
cheap nhl jerseys
youth nhl jerseys
wholesale mlb jerseys
cheap mlb jerseys
cheap nhl jerseys
wholesale nhl jerseys
cheap replica jerseys
wholesale jerseys online
cheap authentic jerseys
cheap jerseys
wholesale authentic jerseys
Cheap nfl super bowl jerseys
cheap nhl jerseys
wholesale basketball jerseys
cheap basketball jerseys
cheap mlb jerseys free shipping
cheap mlb authentic jerseys
mlb jerseys cheap
cheap authentic jerseys

Anna Li said...

cheap authentic nfl jerseys
replica nhl jerseys
cheap replica jerseys
cheap jerseys online
cheap jerseys free shipping
cheap mlb jerseys
Cheap nba jerseys
cheap nfl jerseys uk
cheap super bowl jerseys
cheap nfl Jerseys online
cheap nfl jerseys paypal
cheap football jerseys
cheap nfl jerseys
cheap custom nfl jerseys
discount nfl jerseys
cheap nfl football jerseys
wholesale nfl jerseys
nfl ferseys cheap
wholesale nfl jerseys
cheap replica nfl jerseys
wholesale cheap nfl jerseys
Cheap nfl jerseys free shipping
Cheap nhl jerseys
Wholesale nike nfl jerseys
cheap nike jerseys

Anna Li said...

cheap soccer jerseys online
cheap soccer jerseys
Cheap jerseys from china
wholesale jerseys from china
cheap jerseys china
wholesale cheap jerseys
wholesale jerseys free shipping
wholesale nfl jerseys free shipping
cheap authentic jerseys
Cheap Replica MLB Jerseys
discount nba jerseys
cheap nba jerseys
cheap nfl jerseys
wholesale nfl jerseys
discount nfl jerseys
wholesale nfl jerseys
nfl jerseys cheap
Cheap nhl jerseys
cheap nhl jerseys free shipping
cheap nhl hockey jerseys
NHL Hockey Jerseys Cheap
custom ice hockey jerseys
cheap replica nhl jerseys
wholesale nhl hoceky jerseys
cheap nhl jerseys canada
cheap nhl jerseys online

Anna Li said...

cheap custom nhl jerseys
wholesale nhl jerseys
cheap nhl jerseys
wholesale nhl jerseys
wholesale nhl jerseys canada
cheap nhl authentic jerseys
cheap nike nfl jerseys
wholesale nike nfl jerseys
cheap nike jerseys
cheap jerseys from china
wholesale authentic jerseys
cheap football jerseys
wholesale sports jerseys
wholesale super bowl jerseys
cheap bowl Jerseys
discount jerseys online
cheap jerseys wholesale
discount super bowl jersey
cheap authentic nba jerseys
cheap authentic jerseys
cheap authentic jerseys
cheap nfl authentic jerseys
discount authentic jerseys

Anna Li said...

replica sports jerseys
replica football jerseys
replica nfl football jerseys
tampa bay lightning jerseys
cheap replica football jerseys
new arizona coyotes jerseys
fc barcelona jerseys
cheap jerseys online
discount jerseys free shipping
cheap womens jerseys
cheap jerseys free shipping
cheap mlb jerseys
replica mlb jerseys
discount mlb jerseys
wholesale mlb jerseys
cheap nba houston rockets jerseys
wholesale nba jerseys
cheap nba jerseys wholesale
cheap nba jerseys
cheap nba jerseys free shipping
wholesale nba jerseys
discount nba jerseys
wholesale nba jerseys
nba jerseys wholesale

Anna Li said...

cheap nba jerseys
cheap nba jerseys from china
cheap nba jerseys online
cheap nba free shipping
wholesale nba jerseys
cheap nba jerseys
cheap nfl jerseys for sale
cheap nfl jerseys free shipping
wholesale nfl jerseys
cheap nfl authentic jerseys
cheap nfl jerseys
nhl jerseys cheap
cheap nhl jerseys
cheap nhl jerseys online
custom nhl Jerseys
cheap nhl jerseys canada
cheap custom nhl jerseys
wholesale nhl jerseys
cheap nhl jerseys from china
cheap nike jerseys from china
wholesale nike jerseys from china
wholesale nike jerseys
cheap nike nfl jerseys
cheap nike sports jerseys
cheap nike jerseys
cheap nike nfl jerseys

Anna Li said...

cheap soccer jerseys
wholesale soccer jerseys
wholesale soccer jerseys
cheap soccer jerseys
colts super bowl jerseys
patriots super bowl jerseys
super bowl jerseys
cheap super bowl jerseys
patriots super bowl jersey
super bowl jerseys
super bowl jerseys
new england patriots super bowl jerseys
wholesale super bowl jerseys
cheap authentic super bowl jerseys
cheap jerseys from china
discount jerseys online
wholesale authentic elite jerseys
wholesale authentic jerseys
wholesale authentic nfl jerseys
cheap vancouver canucks jerseys
cheap youth jerseys
cheap real madrid jerseys
wholesale youth jerseys

Anna Li said...

cheap jerseys
cheap stitched jerseys
cheap kids jerseys
cheap jerseys wholesale
cheap jerseys
wholesale jerseys
wholesale nba jerseys free shipping
wholesale nba jerseys
wholesale jerseys free shipping
cheap nfl jerseys
cheap jerseys
Cheap replica soccer jerseys
Cheap jerseys from china
Cheap nfl nike jerseys
Cheap authentic jerseys
Colts Super Bowl Jerseys
Wholesale nhl jerseys
Cheap throwback jerseys
Cheap stitched jerseys
cheap nba jerseys
cheap nfl jerseys
Wholesale cheap jerseys from china

Anna Li said...

cheap jerseys free shipping
Cheap NFL Jerseys China
Cheap NHL Jerseys
Cheap nfl super bowl jerseys
Wholesale replica jerseys
Wholesale Soccer Jerseys
Cheap authentic Jerseys
Cheap authentic Jerseys
cheap soccer jerseys
cheap authentic nfl jerseys
Wholesale NBA Jerseys China
Cheap nhl youth jerseys
cheap nhl jerseys
Wholesale jerseys china
Cheap Basketball Jerseys
nfl jerseys china
cheaper jerseys
Wholesale nike super bowl jerseys
cheap jerseys china
cheap super bowl XLIX jerseys
Cheap nfl jerseys china
Super bowl jerseys wholesale
Wholesale Senior Bowl Jerseys

Anna Li said...

cheap nba jerseys free shipping
nfl jerseys cheap
cheap nhl jerseys china
cheap jerseys from china
Wholesale jerseys from china
Cheap football jerseys
Cheap jerseys wholesale
Replica Super Bowl Jerseys
Cheap jerseys wholesale free shipping
Wholesale nhl jerseys
cheap nhl jerseys wholesale
cheap nhl jerseys canada
replica nhl jerseys
cheap nfl jerseys online
cheap jerseys From china
cheap nfl jerseys china
cheap mlb jerseys
wholesale authentic jerseys
cheap jerseys china
NFL Jerseys Wholesale
Colts super bowl jerseys
China nfl jerseys
cheap sports jerseys
cheap football jerseys
discount nfl jerseys
cheap mlb jerseys
cheap nba jerseys china
nhl jerseys cheap
Cheap Real Madrid Jersey

Anna Li said...

Cheap vancouver canucks jersey
Bayern Munich New Jersey
Cheap Paris Saint Germain Jerseys
wholesale nhl jerseys
cheap basketball jerseys
nhl jerseys cheap
wholesale football jerseys
Wholesale Toronto Raptors Jerseys
Cheap Toronto Raptors Jerseys
cheap real madrid jerseys
cheap juventus jerseys
cheap nfl jerseys online
wholesale football jerseys free shipping
cheap football jerseys
Wholesale MLB jerseys
Wholesale Sports Jerseys
Customized nfl team jerseys
cheap football jerseys
Wholesale basketball jerseys
wholesale jerseys
wholesale jerseys free shipping
cheap nfl jerseys
NFL Jerseys Supply

Anna Li said...

NFL Jerseys China
Cheap NFL Replica Jerseys
Cheap NFL Jerseys China
Cheap NFL Jerseys
Cheap NFL Jerseys
wholesale jerseys
cheap nfl jerseys
wholesale nfl jerseys
wholesale jerseys
cheap jerseys
cheap jerseys free shipping
wholesale jerseys
Wholesale Jerseys
wholesale jerseys from china
wholesale authentic jerseys
cheap authentic jerseys
wholesale Soccer jerseys
Wholesale Cheap Sports Jerseys
discount jerseys
Authentic NFL Jerseys
Cheap NHL Jerseys
About Jerseys News
cheap jerseys wholesale
Sitemap
shoes
ShoesBootsCheap Sitemap
Cheap Christian Louboutin Shoes
Replica Air Jordan Shoes
Discount Nike Shoes
Cheap Air Jordan Shoes
Cheap Nike Shoes
Cheap Air Jordan Shoes Free Shipping